Joshua Hawkins, 34, is a hobby painter from Peoria, Illinois, and got an offer for his biggest commission ever.

The Peoria Journal-Star reports a man, only identified as "Nate", showed Josh an illustration that he'd like to use as a basis for a mural on the side of his business.

Hawkins agreed to paint the mural, saying it's "one of the best paying commissions I've ever had." There was even enough for Joshua to hire a couple of people to help with the painting. Nate gave Josh half of the money upfront, supplied the paint, and told him when he was finished he'd get the rest of the cash.

Josh and his team started the project on Black Friday and finished two days later. The final product was Cookie Monster, standing in front of the Peoria skyline, with the words "World Earth Cookies" written in Russian.

Josh didn't know the context of the writing or the entire artwork for that matter, but he was happy with how it turned out, and so was Nate, who paid him the rest of the money owed.

A few days later, Josh got a call from a different Nate, Nate Comte, the owner of the building.

Nate was furious with Josh for the project. He was out of town over Thanksgiving, and when he came home, there was a big surprise painted on the side of his building.

"What the hell is this mural on my building?" he yelled at Hawkins.

Josh was confused because hadn't Nate hired him to do the project?

"He threatened to call the police on me," Hawkins says. "After that, it started to click."

Comte didn't believe that someone would fake his name to have a painting done on the side of his building.

Ultimate Unexplained logo
Enter your number to get our free mobile app

"I don't think anyone is that stupid," he said. Even now, he isn't sure what to believe.

"It was definitely a weird situation from the beginning, and we should have asked more questions," says Josh, who says the calls and messages to the fake "Nate" have gone unanswered.

"I don't hate art," Comte says. "But don't know what the hell that was."

The best idea I could come up with is an elaborate prank that requires a lot of setup. Perhaps a friend of Comte who didn't just hire a team of artists, but also a graphic designer to illustrate the initial drawing. He would have to know Comte would be out of town. It wasn't cheap though, the paint alone cost a few hundred dollars.

Hawkins says, "I'm still trying to wrap my head around who this guy is, and why he paid me to paint a mural on a building that isn't his."

The 12 Wildest Movie Urban Legends

More From Ultimate Unexplained